Case Update (16 Nov 2026): Rivera Jurado v. Perez Marin; a single knife incident directed at the Mother did not establish a grave risk of harm to the child

The Father, a Mexican citizen and resident, and the Mother, a Mexican citizen and lawful permanent resident of the United States living in Arizona, share an eight-year-old daughter who had lived her whole life in Juárez, Mexico. A 2025 Juárez court order adopted and entered an agreement between the parents that gave the Father physical custody and guardianship and gave the Mother weekend visitation. It also barred either parent from changing the child's habitual residence. In summer 2025, the Mother took the child to Arizona with the Father's consent, for a visit meant to end in September 2025. Instead, she kept the child there, and obtained an Arizona protective order against the Father. In April 2026, the Father filed a Hague petition in the U.S. District Court for the District of Arizona. The Mother, appearing pro se, did not dispute the facts supporting wrongful retention and raised only the Article 13(b) grave risk exception.

The Mother's evidence included text messages in which the Father threatened legal action and threatened to keep her from seeing the child, claims of past violence toward her in the child's presence, the child's statement describing the Father brandishing a knife he "wanted to throw" at the Mother, and the protective order. Even assuming all of it was true, the court held that she had not met her clear and convincing burden. The exception is narrowly drawn, and the question is not where the child would be happiest. The Mother never claimed that the Father had abused, threatened or frightened the child. Relatives' statements that the child was more comfortable with her maternal family showed, at most, that she was happier with her mother. Any harm from separating the child from her mother went to best interests, which is a matter for the Mexican courts.

The court explained that, because the risk must be to the child, domestic violence against the other parent supports grave risk only when it is "sufficiently serious" and sustained enough to show a pattern and propensity. Limited incidents generally do not meet that standard, even if the child witnessed them. The Father's threats to enforce the Mexico order and a single knife incident fell short of the violent threats and sustained abuse necessary to meet a clear and convincing burden. The court also noted that the parents would not be living together after the return. The protective order added little: it disclaimed any custody determination, rested on the same allegations, and was issued without notice to the Father. The court granted the petition and ordered the child returned to the Father in Juárez within thirty days. The Mother must pay transportation costs, and attorneys' fees will be decided under 22 U.S.C. § 9007(b)(3).

Next
Next

Case Update (12 Nov 2026): In re A.M.B.D.; Colorado lacks UCCJEA jurisdiction over a custody petition filed nearly four years after a Hague return to Romania